Status
Not open for further replies.
MtPockets said:
My knees have been popping loud for 2 years now. especially when I first get out of bed in morning. Sounds like loud crack and I can feel it in knees. I was diagnosed May 11, 2006 so maybe it is related to ALS?

God Bless
Big AL


Hi Big AL,

Thank you for sharing your experience with us. According to what you said above, your knees have been popping lound for 2 years. During the last two years, did your neurologist fail to diagnose you with ALS ,not until May 2006 ?

regards,
 
Concerned and need information

Maybe someone out there can help me find information on PMA. My wife has had muscle twitches in her lower legs for approx. two years. She has seen neurologists resulting on no final result of the possible issue.
Just browsing, noticed something that might need tidying up.

I see in the description it says that PMA is a genetic condition, this isn't strictly true. In fact there have been either zero or less than a handful of reported cases of genetically inherited PMA. There are a group of genetically inherited conditions, the spinal muscular atrophies, which are genetically inherited and affect only the lower motor neurones, but these are different to progressive muscular atrophy.

PMA affects only the lower motor neurones and so causes wasting/atrophy and fasciculations but in the absence of UMN signs such as spasticity, brisk reflexes, or the Babinski sign. Patients with PMA survive longer than patients with ALS and in some cases symptoms can be restricted to the arms or legs for a long time before spreading elsewhere in the body. There may be two subtypes, one with a patchy distribution and one with a leg distribution. In the latter case progression is unpredictable, whilst in the latter there is a prolonged latency period between the progression from legs to arms, and then again to the bulbar region. PMA is not rapidly progressive. If it is it's probably not PMA but ALS.

Also it's not true that PMA affects only the lower limbs. All muscles in the body, from head to neck to arms to trunk to legs to toes are ennervated by upper and lower motor neurones. So you can have LMN dysfunction which affects your tongue (atrophy) or UMN dysfunction which affects your ankles (brisk reflexes).

In contrast to patients with ALS, PMA patients are highly unlikely to have a bulbar onset of disease, do not manifest signs of emotional lability / pseudobulbar affect, and so far as I have been able to measure, show no signs of the cognitive abnormalities encounted in a proportion of patients with ALS.

Many PMA patients don't know they have it or don't know the difference from typical ALS. It's hard to diagnose and strictly speaking you need to have had LMN-only symptoms for 4 years or more to be certain, and even then about 50% of LMN-only syndromes progress to ALS (known as "PMA->ALS"), sometimes as much as 26 years later.

When I get the time I'm going to be writing an article on Wikipedia about PMA, please keep your eyes peeled for it soon!

Cheers

Paul Wicks
 
your wife

Hi Rick

Hope your wife does not have PMA or ALS. The important thing is that you go to an ALS specialist to rule out things. Local neurologist are great doctors but the local one we see (in between every 4 months to ALS university specialist) has only seen 2 or 3
PMA/ALS patients, where ALS university specialist sees hundreds of cases.

Good luck and God bless.

Patty
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top