Advice on FTD & ALS specialists in AZ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cereus

Active member
Joined
Nov 5, 2009
Messages
43
Reason
Lost a loved one
Diagnosis
12/2009
Country
US
State
AZ
City
Southern
Has anyone had experience with either the Banner Institute or Mayo Clinic in Phoenix? We are an unusual case as my hb has FTD and Bulbar onset ALS. We went to an ALS Clinic in Tucson this morning which was ok, but left me thinking we should try somewhere that may have more experience with the two diseases together. I will ask the same question on the FTD Forum.
Thanks.
 
Being a Tucsonian I've had contact with the ALS Assoc. in Phoenix. My contact is Kim Hughes at 602-297-3800 or Matt Hildebrandt at 520-444-0712. They've been helpful with suggestions about ALS and might have info on FTD as well...I know she participates in the clinics held at Banner. Good luck to you.
 
Hi. Barden here. We have been to Mayo twice; seeing Dr. Bosch. I am not too impressed as they are in no hurry to diagnose anything...just wait for you to go back home and get worse. They told us to come back in six months in September. My husband is no longer able to be understood when he speaks. When I called the nurse and asked her what I should do when he chokes she said "well if he turns blue, call 911"
 
Thanks 55coop and Bardem,
I'll give the contacts a call. We've got an appt with Mayo for later in the month and hope for the best. Barden, I got the same info on choking only said a bit nicer. The speech path said do not use the Heimleich, do not pat on the back, do not offer water as these can make it worse. Sadly we can only sit and watch and call 911 if they cannot clear the obstruction naturally. I'm no expert, so anyone out there who knows more, please let us know.
 
Follow-up
Barden,
We pretty much got the same at Mayo. We've had two docs diagnose ALS and FTD and were not looking for a 3rd opinion but some help. Mayo wanted to start again with new EMG and NCV testing. I get the need for "their own" data but my hb said no. The doc was peeved, not really understanding how the mind of a pFTD works. They have no idea how hard it was for me to get him there in the first place.
So, I'm home and will come up with a new plan. Thanks for your input. I hope you are finding help somewhere too.

Fifty5coop,
Thanks for that but it looks like traveling to Phoenix is too much for my hb. I'll keep trying here in town.
 
Hi cereus, my mom was diagnosed'ed with FTD two years before her ALS diagnosed. She was seeing a neuro who specializes in FTD at the time. She was then referred to the only Certified ALS Clinic in our region, and there is only one doctor who sees the patients. I think that diagnosed, and treatment are slow in coming because both of these diseases are so rare. Maybe the Doc's are unsure of themselves. Of the four neuro's I've had the "honor" to meet with, none of them had a good bedside manner--very arrogant. I feel, that even though they have this "God like" attitude, we have no choice. In our case, the Doc knows his stuff, and he's the only ALS Specialist in our area. Of course he's been educated, and knows about FTD--he's a neuro. BUT he did offend my mom during her first few appointments, acting like she was not even in the room, ignoring her while she was speaking because he couldn't understand, and acting like she was totally mentally challenged. She never said anything about it but I sure did, and he now treats her with respect.
Also, there is a book titled, "What if it's not Alzheimer's?" It is a caregiver's guide, and is REALLY good. It's all about FTD.

In our case, the regional medical center we go to, has a neurosciences clinic that deals with everything. I would think that Mayo would have a similar type clinic. My mom only sees the one Doc, she wants nothing to do with more appointments and medical stuff. I know there are a couple of people on here who are dealing with this dual diagnosed, maybe they have better information.

Good luck,
Laura
 
Hi all,
Good news! Yesterday my hb and I saw a new (to us) neurologist affiliated with Banner Good Samaritan's ALS Clinic in Phoenix. He was EXCELLENT! He understood FTD and ALS. He treated my hb with dignity, kindness and compassion. He answered our questions thoroughly. He gave us reality tinged with hope and help. So if you are not happy with your doctor, keep looking.

Thanks fifty5coop, Kim at the ALS Association was wonderful. She helped convince my hb to go to Phoenix for one more try.

Thanks Laura, too bad so many of the doctors forget their main purpose when seeing patients. I'll get the book too - many have recommended it.
 
THAT IS EXCELLENT NEWS! I love this "He gave us reality tinged with hope and help"!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top